Harf
Script shown with the Urdu

سنڈیسے آتے ہیں Sandese Aate Hain — The Messages Keep Coming

Javed Akhtar

1945– living

Geet

A soldier is reading letters from home, and every letter asks him the same question: when will you come back to the house? The letters are the whole country, and the question in them is the whole war. This is the song of the soldier away at the border, written by Javed Akhtar for J. P. Dutta's Border, the 1997 film about the 1971 war.

Five passages ahead. The first three are the letters themselves, and they keep asking. The fourth is the mother's letter. The last one is the soldier's reply, and it is the only passage he is allowed to have.

01  — sandese aate hain, hamein tarpate hain

سنڈیسے آتے ہیں، ہمیں تڑپاتے ہیں
تو چٹھی آتی ہے، تو پوچھ جاتی ہے
کہ گھر کب آؤگے، کہ گھر کب آؤگے
لکھو کب آؤگے
کہ تم بن یہ گھر سونا سونا ہے

संदेसे आते हैं, हमें तड़पाते हैं
तो चिट्ठी आती है, तो पूछ जाती है
कि घर कब आओगे, कि घर कब आओगे
लिखो कब आओगे
कि तुम बिन ये घर सूना सूना है

sandese aate hain, hamein tarpate hain
to chitthi aati hai, to poochh jaati hai
ki ghar kab aaoge, ki ghar kab aaoge
likho kab aaoge
ki tum bin ye ghar soona soona hai

The messages keep coming, and they torment us. A letter arrives, and it asks and goes: when will you come home, when will you come home? Write when you will come. Without you, this house is empty, empty.

The refrain does its work with the doubled words. Soon a soona, empty empty, is the sound of a house with one person missing from it, and the doubling is the song's signature. The question is asked twice, ghar kab aaoge, and then sharpened, likho kab aaoge, write when you will come. The messages tarpate hain, they torment, and the torment is the love: the question is unbearable precisely because it is the only thing the letters contain.

سندیسہ sandese
messages sent with somebody travelling
چٹھی chitthi
a letter
سونا soona
empty, with nobody in it

02  — kisi dilwaali ne, kisi matwaali ne

کسی دل والی نے، کسی مت والی نے
ہمیں خط لکھا ہے، کہ ہم سے پوچھا ہے
کسی کی سانسوں نے، کسی کی دھڑکن نے
کسی کی چوڑی نے، کسی کے کنگن نے
کسی کے کجرے نے، کسی کے گجرے نے
مہکتی صبحوں نے، مچلتی شاموں نے
اکیلی راتوں نے، ادھوری باتوں نے
ترستی باہوں نے
اور پوچھا ہے ترستی نگاہوں نے
کہ گھر کب آؤگے، کہ گھر کب آؤگے
لکھو کب آؤگے
کہ تم بن یہ دل سونا سونا ہے

किसी दिलवाली ने, किसी मतवाली ने
हमें खत लिखा है, कि हमसे पूछा है
किसी की साँसों ने, किसी की धड़कन ने
किसी की चूड़ी ने, किसी के कंगन ने
किसी के कजरे ने, किसी के गजरे ने
महकती सुबहों ने, मचलती शामों ने
अकेली रातों ने, अधूरी बातों ने
तरसती बाहों ने
और पूछा है तरसती निगाहों ने
कि घर कब आओगे, कि घर कब आओगे
लिखो कब आओगे
कि तुम बिन ये दिल सूना सूना है

kisi dilwaali ne, kisi matwaali ne
hamein khat likha hai, ki hum se poochha hai
kisi ki saanson ne, kisi ki dhadkan ne
kisi ki choodi ne, kisi ke kangan ne
kisi ke kajre ne, kisi ke gajre ne
mahakti subahon ne, machalti shaamon ne
akeli raaton ne, adhoori baaton ne
tarasti baahon ne
aur poochha hai tarasti nigaahon ne
ki ghar kab aaoge, ki ghar kab aaoge
likho kab aaoge
ki tum bin ye dil soona soona hai

Some darling one, some mad one, has written to us and asked us. Someone's breaths asked, someone's heartbeat, someone's bangles, someone's bracelets, someone's kohl, someone's garlands. The fragrant mornings asked, the restless evenings, the lonely nights, the unfinished words, the longing arms, and the longing eyes asked too: when will you come home? Write when you will come. Without you, this heart is empty, empty.

The passage turns the beloved into a catalogue of her own parts, and every part asks. The device is the folk song's list, and Javed Akhtar extends it until the list becomes the woman: breath, heartbeat, bangle, bracelet, kohl, garland, mornings, evenings, nights, words, arms, eyes. Each item is a small metonymy, and the refrain's answer changes in the last line: this time it is the dil, the heart, that is empty, not the house. The beloved has moved the emptiness indoors.

متوالی matwaali
one who goes about intoxicated with living
چوڑی choodi
a glass bangle
کنگن kangan
a heavy bracelet, usually metal
گجرا gajra
a string of flowers wound into the hair

03  — mohabbat waalon ne, hamaare yaaron ne

محبت والوں نے، ہمارے یاروں نے
ہمیں یہ لکھا ہے، کہ ہم سے پوچھا ہے
ہمارے گاؤں نے، آم کی چھاؤں نے
پرانے پیپل نے، برستے بادل نے
کھیت کھلیانوں نے، ہارے میدانوں نے
بسنتی بیلوں نے، جھومتی بیلوں نے
لچکتے جھولوں نے، بہکتے پھولوں نے
چٹکتی کلیوں نے
اور پوچھا ہے گاؤں کی گلیوں نے
کہ گھر کب آؤگے، کہ گھر کب آؤگے
لکھو کب آؤگے
کہ تم بن گاؤں سونا سونا ہے

मोहब्बत वालों ने, हमारे यारों ने
हमें ये लिखा है, कि हमसे पूछा है
हमारे गाँवों ने, आम की छाँवों ने
पुराने पीपल ने, बरसते बादल ने
खेत खलियानों ने, हारे मैदानों ने
बसंती बेलों ने, झूमती बेलों ने
लचकते झूलों ने, बहकते फूलों ने
चटकती कलियों ने
और पूछा है गाँव की गलियों ने
कि घर कब आओगे, कि घर कब आओगे
लिखो कब आओगे
कि तुम बिन गाँव सूना सूना है

mohabbat waalon ne, hamaare yaaron ne
hamein ye likha hai, ki hum se poochha hai
hamaare gaaon ne, aam ki chhaon ne
puraane peepal ne, baraste baadal ne
khet khaliyaanon ne, haare maidaanon ne
basanti belon ne, jhoomti belon ne
lachakte jhoolon ne, bahakte phoolon ne
chatakti kaliyon ne
aur poochha hai gaaon ki galiyon ne
ki ghar kab aaoge, ki ghar kab aaoge
likho kab aaoge
ki tum bin gaaon soona soona hai

The loving ones, our friends, have written this to us and asked. Our villages asked, the mango shade, the old banyan, the raining clouds, the fields and threshing floors, the tired meadows, the spring vines, the swaying vines, the swinging swings, the intoxicated flowers, the bursting buds, and the lanes of the village asked: when will you come home? Write when you will come. Without you, the village is empty, empty.

The passage does for the village what the last one did for the beloved. The catalogue is all geography now: mango shade, banyan, clouds, fields, vines, swings, flowers, buds, lanes. The village is a list of the places a boy grew up in, and each one asks the question that only a soldier hears. The change in the refrain's last line, gaaon soona, the village empty, widens the emptiness from the house to everything, which is the passage's point: the soldier is missed by the geography itself.

کھلیان khaliyaanon
threshing floors
بسنتی basanti
of spring; the yellow of mustard flower
بیل belon
creepers, vines
چٹکنا chatakti
bursting open, cracking apart

04  — kabhi ek mamta ki, pyaar ki ganga ki

کبھی ایک مٹھی کی، پیار کی گنگا کی
وہ چٹھی آتی ہے، ساتھ وہ لاتی ہے
میرے دن بچپن کے، کھیل وہ آنگن کے
وہ سایہ آنچل کا، وہ ٹیکا کاجل کا
وہ لوری راتوں میں، وہ نرمی ہاتھوں میں
وہ چاہت آنکھوں میں، وہ چنتا باتوں میں
بگاڑنا اوپر سے، محبت اندر سے
کرے وہ دیوی ماں
یہیں ہر خط میں پوچھے میری ماں
کہ گھر کب آؤگے، کہ گھر کب آؤگے
لکھو کب آؤگے
کہ تم بن آنگن سونا سونا ہے

कभी एक ममता की, प्यार की गंगा की
वो चिट्ठी आती है, साथ वो लाती है
मेरे दिन बचपन के, खेल वो आँगन के
वो साया आँचल का, वो टीका काजल का
वो लोरी रातों में, वो नर्मी हाथों में
वो चाहत आँखों में, वो चिंता बातों में
बिगाड़ना ऊपर से, मोहब्बत अंदर से
करे वो देवी माँ
यहीं हर खत में पूछे मेरी माँ
कि घर कब आओगे, कि घर कब आओगे
लिखो कब आओगे
कि तुम बिन आँगन सूना सूना है

kabhi ek mamta ki, pyaar ki ganga ki
voh chitthi aati hai, saath voh laati hai
mere din bachpan ke, khel voh aangan ke
voh saaya aanchal ka, voh tika kaajal ka
voh lori raaton mein, voh narmi haathon mein
voh chaahat aankhon mein, voh chinta baaton mein
bigaadna upar se, mohabbat andar se
kare voh devi maa
yahin har khat mein poochhe meri maa
ki ghar kab aaoge, ki ghar kab aaoge
likho kab aaoge
ki tum bin aangan soona soona hai

Sometimes a letter of a mother's love, of love's own Ganga, arrives, and it brings with it my childhood days, the games of the courtyard, the shade of the dupatta, the tika of kohl, the lullabies in the nights, the softness in the hands, the love in the eyes, the worry in the words. Scolding from the outside, love from the inside: that is what mother, the goddess, does. And in every letter my mother asks: when will you come home? Write when you will come. Without you, the courtyard is empty, empty.

The passage is the song's heart, and it earns the position by what it carries. The letter of the mother brings the whole childhood with it: the games, the dupatta's shade, the tika, the lullabies, the soft hands, the worried words. The line about the scolding is the song's most precise portrait: bigaadna upar se, mohabbat andar se, harsh on the outside, love within. And the mother asks the same question everyone asks, but the refrain's answer changes once more: the courtyard, aangan, is empty. The house, the heart, the village, the courtyard: the song has moved the emptiness back to where it started, which is where the mother is.

ممتا mamta
a mother's love, as its own kind of feeling
ٹیکہ tika
a mark set on the forehead
کاجل kaajal
kohl, made from lamp soot
دیوی devi
a goddess

05  — oh guzarne waali hawa bata

اوہ گزرنے والی ہوا بتا
میرا اتنا کام کرے گی کیا
میرے گاؤں جا، میرے دوستوں میں سلام دے
میری گاؤں میں ہے جو وہ گلی
جہاں رہتی ہے میری دلربا
اسے میرے پیار کا جام دے
وہیں تھوڑی دور ہے گھر میرا
میرا گھر میں ہے میری بوڑھی ماں
میری ماں کے پاؤں کو چھو کے
اسے اس کے بیٹا کا نام دے
اوہ گزرنے والی ہوا ذرا
میرے دوستوں، میری دلربا، میری ماں کو میرا پیغام دے
انہیں جا کے کہئے یہ پیغام دے
میں واپس آؤں گا، میں واپس آؤں گا
پھر اپنے گاؤں میں، اسی کی چھاؤں میں
کہ ماں کے آنچل سے، گاؤں کے پیپل سے
کسی کے کاجل سے
کیا جو وعدہ تھا وہ نبھاؤں گا
میں ایک دن آؤں گا

ओ गुज़रने वाली हवा बता
मेरा इतना काम करेगी क्या
मेरे गाँव जा, मेरे दोस्तों में सलाम दे
मेरी गाँव में है जो वो गली
जहाँ रहती है मेरी दिलरुबा
उसे मेरे प्यार का जाम दे
वहीं थोड़ी दूर है घर मेरा
मेरा घर में है मेरी बूढ़ी माँ
मेरी माँ के पैरों को छूके
उसे उसके बेटा का नाम दे
ओ गुज़रने वाली हवा ज़रा
मेरे दोस्तों, मेरी दिलरुबा, मेरी माँ को मेरा पैग़ाम दे
उन्हें जाके कहिए ये पैग़ाम दे
मैं वापस आऊँगा, मैं वापस आऊँगा
फिर अपने गाँव में, उसी की छाँव में
कि माँ के आँचल से, गाँव के पीपल से
किसी के काजल से
किया जो वादा था वो निभाऊँगा
मैं एक दिन आऊँगा

oh guzarne waali hawa bata
mera itna kaam karegi kya
mere gaaon ja, mere doston mein salaam de
meri gaaon mein hai jo voh gali
jahan rahti hai meri dilruba
use mere pyaar ka jaam de
vahiin thodi door hai ghar mera
mera ghar mein hai meri buddhi maa
meri maa ke paon ko chhoo ke
use uske beta ka naam de
oh guzarne waali hawa zara
mere doston, meri dilruba, meri maa ko mera paighaam de
unhen jaake kahiye ye paighaam de
main vaapas aaunga, main vaapas aaunga
phir apne gaaon mein, usi ki chhaon mein
ki maa ke aanchal se, gaaon ke peepal se
kisi ke kaajal se
kiya jo vaada tha voh nibhaaunga
main ek din aaunga

Oh wind that passes by, tell me, will you do this much for me? Go to my village, give my greetings to my friends. In my village there is a lane where my beloved lives: give her the cup of my love. A little further from there is my house, and in my house is my old mother. Touch my mother's feet and give her her son's name. Oh passing wind, take my message to my friends, my beloved, my mother. Go and deliver it. I will come back, I will come back, to my village, in its shade. I will keep the promise made by a mother's dupatta, the village banyan, someone's kohl. I will come one day.

The passage is the soldier's reply, and it is entrusted to the wind, the one messenger that cannot be stopped at the border. The route is drawn precisely: the lane of the beloved, the cup of love, then the mother's house, the feet touched, the son's name. The wind is asked for the two messages, and the vow follows: main vaapas aaunga, twice, then the promise kept in the currency of the earlier passages, the dupatta, the banyan, the kohl. The song's last line is its answer to every letter: main ek din aaunga, I will come one day. The question and the answer are the same length, and the answer is a promise, not a date.

دلربا dilruba
the one who steals your heart
جام jaam
a cup, the wine in it
پیغام paighaam
a message

Reading it whole

The song is built on one question, and the question never changes: ghar kab aaoge, when will you come home? Every passage is a different person or thing asking it, and the song's genius is that it never lets the soldier answer until the very end. The letters arrive, the messages torment him, and the refrain keeps the question open while the whole country files past, asking.

The first passages make the country itself the writer. The beloved's breath asks, her bangles ask, her kohl and her garlands ask. The village asks through its mango shade, its old banyan, its fields and its lanes. The device of the catalogue, one thing after another asking the same question, makes the absence a geography: the soldier is missed by every object he left behind.

The fourth passage is the mother's letter, and it is the one that turns the song. The letter arrives carrying his childhood: the games in the courtyard, the shade of her dupatta, the tika of kohl, the lullabies, the scolding that was love from the outside. The mother's question is the same as everyone's, but it lands differently because the whole letter is the proof of what he is missing.

The last passage is the reply, and the reply is a message sent by the wind. Greet my friends, take the beloved the cup of my love, touch my mother's feet and give her her son's name. Then the vow, the song's only answer to the question: I will come back, I will keep the promise I made, I will come one day. The film's final title card and the singing of the entire border at once made this the anthem of every Indian soldier since, and it is the only song in the collection in which the letters and the answer are the same length.

Recordings

  • Sonu Nigam

    From Border (1997), composed by Anu Malik. The film version from Border, sung for the soldiers of the 1971 war.

Read next

All 128 poems, A to Z

Text and rights

Devanagari text supplied and checked by a reader who knows the language. The Urdu script and the transliteration follow that reading.

The song is from the film Border (1997), music Anu Malik, lyrics Javed Akhtar. The refrain returns between passages in the recording more often than it is printed here.

Javed Akhtar is alive and the song is recent work. It is quoted here as the subject of Harf's own criticism: the translation, the reading of each passage and the essay around them are original work written for this page. If you hold the rights and would like something changed, tell us on Instagram.