Harf
Script shown with the Urdu

کل چودھویں کی رات تھی Kal Chaudhvin Ki Raat Thi — Last Night Was The Fourteenth Night

Ibn-e-Insha

1927– 1978

Ghazal

The moon was full last night and the entire town stayed up arguing about it. Some people said that is the moon. Others said no, that is her face. And one man standing in the middle of the crowd, who could have settled it in a sentence, laughed and kept quiet.

Ibn-e-Insha wrote travel books and newspaper columns as well as poetry, and the ghazal reads the way he wrote those: easily, in a speaking voice. Ten couplets ahead, each one a new guess at what the moon was. The ninth is where he finally says what he thinks of her.

01  — kal chaudhvin ki raat thi shab bhar raha charcha tera Matla · the opening

کل چودھویں کی رات تھی شب بھر رہا چرچا ترا
کچھ نے کہا یہ چاند ہے کچھ نے کہا چہرا ترا

कल चौदहवीं की रात थी शब भर रहा चर्चा तिरा
कुछ ने कहा ये चाँद है कुछ ने कहा चेहरा तिरा

kal chaudhvin ki raat thi shab bhar raha charcha tera
kuchh ne kaha ye chaand hai kuchh ne kaha chehra tera

Last night was the fourteenth night, and all night long the talk was of you. Some said that is the moon. Some said no, that is your face.

The fourteenth night of the lunar month is when the moon is full, so the setting is doing the compliment before anybody opens their mouth. He reports it as an argument rather than a comparison. He is not saying she is like the moon. He is saying a crowd of people could not agree which of the two they were looking at.

چودھویں chaudhvin
the fourteenth; the night of the full moon
چرچا charcha
talk, discussion, the thing everybody is saying

02  — ham bhi vahin maujood the ham se bhi sab poochha kiye

ہم بھی وہیں موجود تھے ہم سے بھی سب پوچھا کیے
ہم ہنس دیے ہم چپ رہے منظور تھا پردا ترا

हम भी वहीं मौजूद थे हम से भी सब पूछा किए
हम हँस दिए हम चुप रहे मंज़ूर था पर्दा तिरा

ham bhi vahin maujood the ham se bhi sab poochha kiye
ham hans diye ham chup rahe manzoor tha parda tera

I was standing right there, and they kept asking me too. I laughed. I said nothing. Your privacy was acceptable to me.

Manzoor is the word for a request granted or a condition accepted, so the last line is the language of agreement rather than of sacrifice. He is not being noble about it. He is reporting that he consented to the terms. And the two flat verbs before it, laughed and stayed quiet, are exactly what somebody does when they know the answer and have decided not to give it.

منظور manzoor
accepted, agreed to, granted
پردا parda
the veil; here, privacy, being kept out of view

03  — is shahar mein kis se milen ham se to chhooteen mehfilen

اس شہر میں کس سے ملیں ہم سے تو چھوٹیں محفلیں
ہر شخص تیرا نام لے ہر شخص دیوانہ ترا

इस शहर में किस से मिलें हम से तो छूटीं महफ़िलें
हर शख़्स तेरा नाम ले हर शख़्स दीवाना तिरा

is shahar mein kis se milen ham se to chhooteen mehfilen
har shakhs tera naam le har shakhs deewana tera

Who is there left to meet in this city? Gatherings have finished with me. Every single person says your name. Every single person is out of their mind about you.

The complaint is not loneliness, it is competition. He has stopped going out because every room in town is having the same conversation he is having, which turns his private condition into a crowd. Chhooteen is the verb for something slipping out of your hands rather than being given up, so the gatherings left him rather than the other way round.

محفل mehfil
a gathering; an evening of company or music
شخص shakhs
a person, an individual

04  — kooche ko tere chhod kar jogi hi ban jayen magar

کوچے کو تیرے چھوڑ کر جوگی ہی بن جائیں مگر
جنگل ترے پربت ترے بستی تری صحرا ترا

कूचे को तेरे छोड़ कर जोगी ही बन जाएँ मगर
जंगल तिरे पर्बत तिरे बस्ती तिरी सहरा तिरा

kooche ko tere chhod kar jogi hi ban jayen magar
jangal tere parbat tere basti teri sahra tera

I could leave your street behind and simply turn ascetic. Except that the forests are yours. The mountains are yours. The settlement is yours, and so is the desert.

A jogi is a wandering renunciant, the Sanskrit-derived word rather than a Persian one, and reaching for it puts the whole subcontinent's tradition of walking away inside an Urdu ghazal. Then the second line closes the exits one at a time, four of them in a single line, ending on the emptiest place available. Even the desert is taken.

کوچہ koocha
a lane or street
جوگی jogi
a wandering ascetic, a renunciant
صحرا sahra
the desert, the wilderness

05  — ham aur rasm-e-bandagi aashuftagi uftaadagi

ہم اور رسمِ بندگی آشفتگی افتادگی
احسان ہے کیا کیا ترا اے حسنِ بے پروا ترا

हम और रस्म-ए-बंदगी आशुफ़्तगी उफ़्तादगी
एहसान है क्या क्या तिरा ऐ हुस्न-ए-बे-परवा तिरा

ham aur rasm-e-bandagi aashuftagi uftaadagi
ehsan hai kya kya tera ai husn-e-be-parva tera

Me, and the whole ceremony of servitude, the derangement, the falling down. What favours you have done me, you careless beauty. All of them yours.

Three abstract nouns in a row, each one a further stage of collapse: the ritual of service, then coming apart, then being flat on the ground. Ehsan means a favour done, and he thanks her for all three, which is either gratitude or pure sarcasm. Be-parva, careless, settles it. She was not paying attention while she did him these kindnesses.

بندگی bandagi
servitude, devotion; the condition of being somebody's servant
آشفتگی aashuftagi
distraction, being scattered or deranged
بے پروا be-parva
careless, indifferent, not paying attention

06  — do ashk jaane kis liye palkon pe aa kar tik gaye

دو اشک جانے کس لیے پلکوں پہ آ کر ٹک گئے
الطاف کی بارش تری اکرام کا دریا ترا

दो अश्क जाने किस लिए पलकों पे आ कर टिक गए
अल्ताफ़ की बारिश तिरी इकराम का दरिया तिरा

do ashk jaane kis liye palkon pe aa kar tik gaye
altaf ki barish teri ikram ka dariya tera

Two tears, for reasons I could not tell you, came and settled on my lashes. Your downpour of kindnesses. Your river of generosity.

Two tears, counted. Then the second line answers with a rainstorm and a river, and the mismatch is the joke. Everything she gives arrives in enormous quantities and what reaches him amounts to two. Jaane kis liye, who knows why, is him pretending not to understand his own face.

اشک ashk
a tear
الطاف altaf
kindnesses, the plural of lutf
اکرام ikram
honours, acts of generosity

07  — ai be-daregh o be-amaan ham ne kabhi ki hai fughaan

اے بے دریغ و بے اماں ہم نے کبھی کی ہے فغاں
ہم کو تری وحشت سہی ہم کو سہی سودا ترا

ऐ बे-दरेग़ ओ बे-अमाँ हम ने कभी की है फ़ुग़ाँ
हम को तिरी वहशत सही हम को सही सौदा तिरा

ai be-daregh o be-amaan ham ne kabhi ki hai fughaan
ham ko teri vahshat sahi ham ko sahi sauda tera

You who spare nothing and give no quarter: have I ever once cried out? Let the frenzy be mine, then. Let the madness for you be mine.

Sahi is the word for accepting a worse deal than the one you wanted, and it lands twice here. He does not deny the derangement. He agrees to it, keeps it, files it under his own name. Asking whether he has ever complained, in the middle of a poem that is entirely complaint, is the closest this ghazal comes to a joke against itself.

بے دریغ be-daregh
unsparing, withholding nothing
فغاں fughaan
a cry of anguish, a wail
سودا sauda
madness, obsession; also a bargain or transaction

08  — ham par ye sakhti ki nazar ham hain faqir-e-rahguzar

ہم پر یہ سختی کی نظر ہم ہیں فقیرِ رہ گزر
رستہ کبھی روکا ترا دامن کبھی تھاما ترا

हम पर ये सख़्ती की नज़र हम हैं फ़क़ीर-ए-रहगुज़र
रस्ता कभी रोका तिरा दामन कभी थामा तिरा

ham par ye sakhti ki nazar ham hain faqir-e-rahguzar
rasta kabhi roka tera daaman kabhi thama tera

That hard look, aimed at me. I am only a beggar at the side of the road. When did I ever block your way, or catch hold of your hem?

A defence entered in court. Faqir-e-rahguzar is a beggar of the roadside, somebody who occupies no space and asks from a distance, and the two charges he denies are the two things a nuisance would actually do. He has not obstructed her and he has not grabbed at her. The look he is getting is for existing on the route.

فقیرِ رہ گزر faqir-e-rahguzar
a beggar at the side of the road
دامن daaman
the hem or skirt of a garment

09  — haan haan teri soorat haseen lekin tu aisa bhi nahin

ہاں ہاں تری صورت حسیں لیکن تو ایسا بھی نہیں
اک شخص کے اشعار سے شہرہ ہوا کیا کیا ترا

हाँ हाँ तिरी सूरत हसीं लेकिन तू ऐसा भी नहीं
इक शख़्स के अशआ'र से शोहरा हुआ क्या क्या तिरा

haan haan teri soorat haseen lekin tu aisa bhi nahin
ik shakhs ke ashaar se shohra hua kya kya tera

Yes, yes, your face is lovely. But you are not all that. Look at the reputation you got out of one man's couplets.

The turn comes with no warning after eight couplets of surrender. Haan haan, yes yes, is the impatient double you use when conceding a point in order to get past it. Then he tells a beloved to her face that her fame is his doing. It is the only place in the poem where he holds anything at all, and what he holds is the fact that he wrote her.

صورت soorat
face, appearance
اشعار ashaar
couplets, the plural of sher
شہرہ shohra
fame, being widely talked about

10  — bedard sunni ho to chal kahta hai kya achhi ghazal Maqta · signed by the poet

بے درد سننی ہو تو چل کہتا ہے کیا اچھی غزل
عاشق ترا رسوا ترا شاعر ترا انشاؔ ترا

बेदर्द सुननी हो तो चल कहता है क्या अच्छी ग़ज़ल
आशिक़ तिरा रुस्वा तिरा शाइर तिरा 'इंशा' तिरा

bedard sunni ho to chal kahta hai kya achhi ghazal
aashiq tera rusva tera shair tera 'insha' tera

You heartless thing, if you want to hear something, come along. The man writes a very fine ghazal. Your lover, your disgraced one, your poet, your Insha.

The maqta, and he spends it introducing himself to her four times over. Aashiq, rusva, shair, Insha: lover, disgrace, poet, name. Each one is followed by tera, so all four belong to her, including the disgrace and including him. Speaking about himself in the third person while inviting her to come and listen is the manoeuvre of somebody who has run out of ways to be in the room.

رسوا rusva
disgraced; publicly shamed
شاعر shair
a poet

Reading it whole

Every second line ends on the same word, tera, yours, and after ten couplets that one possessive has taken over the world. The forests are yours. The mountains, the town, the desert. The rain of kindness and the river of favour. By the end the lover is yours, the disgrace is yours, the poet is yours. He cannot get out from under it, and the proof is the last word of every line, which is never his.

The first two couplets are a scene rather than a declaration, and they are better for it. A crowd, a full moon, an argument, and him standing in it while people keep turning to ask what he thinks. He laughs. He says nothing. Manzoor tha parda tera: your privacy was acceptable to me. He was holding the one piece of information the whole street wanted, and he spent the night protecting her with it.

Most people who know this ghazal know its fourth couplet. He could give up her street entirely, he says, become a wandering ascetic and go. Then the second line shuts every exit in turn. The forests are yours, the mountains are yours, the settlement is yours, the desert is yours. There is no elsewhere left to walk to. Renunciation was the only plan he had, and it leads straight back into her territory.

And then, out of nowhere, the ghazal turns round and slaps her. Yes, yes, your face is beautiful. But you are not all that. Look what fame you have got out of one man's couplets. After eight couplets of surrender that is a poet telling a beloved he made her, and it is the only moment in the poem where he is holding anything. He knows exactly how much of her reputation is in his own handwriting.

The last couplet takes it back and does not take it back. If you want to hear something cruel, he says, come along, the man writes a very good ghazal. Then four things in a row, every one of them hers: your lover, your disgraced one, your poet, your Insha. He hands himself over in instalments, and the final instalment is his own name. Jagjit Singh's recording is how most people know it.

How it rhymes

Every second line closes on the same word — ترا , tera. That repetition is the radif. The rhyme falling just before it is the qafiya: The -a ending before the refrain: charcha, chehra, parda, deewana, sahra, be-parwa, dariya, sauda, thama, Insha. Hearing the two land together at the close of every sher is most of what makes this form sound the way it does.

Recordings

Read next

All 128 poems, A to Z

Text and rights

Devanagari text supplied and checked by a reader who knows the language. The Urdu script and the transliteration follow that reading.

Sung versions take a selection of the ten couplets rather than all of them.

Ibn-e-Insha died in 1978, so this poem is still in copyright. It is quoted here as the subject of Harf's own criticism: the translation, the reading of each couplet and the essay around them are original work written for this page. If you hold the rights and would like something changed, tell us on Instagram.